It has been widely reported that, when the terrorist organization Hamas crossed the Gaza border Oct. 7 and murdered some 1,200 Israelis, mostly civilians and many of them women and children, one of its goals was to provoke a devastating military response by Israel. That response, the thinking went, might be massive enough to drive a wedge between Israel and other nations and upend peace talks between Israel and Saudi Arabia. In this respect, Hamas was wildly successful.
A number of countries have cut off diplomatic relations with Israel; splits have riven the American Jewish community and the Democratic Party; and antisemitic incidents have soared around the world.
In short, Hamas has sowed more chaos, more hatred of Jews and Israel, than it could reasonably have hoped. Indeed, in a haunting echo of the U.S. response to 9/11, which did untold damage to American credibility and to American and Middle Eastern lives and resources, Israel has unleashed its own brutality on non-Hamas Palestinians disproportionate in magnitude to the unspeakable horror that provoked it.
At this point, it may take generations to undo the new levels of hatred the Israeli-Gazan war has spurred. But we as Americans have a responsibility to keep Hamas from getting its way, by pressing our government to call for a ceasefire as well as the return of Hamas’ hostages, and to renew efforts to achieve a two-state solution — a solution that recognizes both Israel’s right to exist and the Palestinians’ right to their own homeland, with a fair and lasting resolution of such related issues as Israel’s unlawful settlements in the West Bank.